Skip to main content.
Navigation:

Cooperstown Menus

Cooperstown Restaurant Guide

A complete list of Cooperstown restaurants - click a name for a menu.

Add a Restaurant/Menu
Free Online Menu for every restaurant in town.
Openings/Closings? Tip us off
Updated 7/2/15
New Cooperstown Restaurants
Slices Pizzeria - opened 6/13/15
Mt Fuji - opened 6/4/15
New York BBQ - opened 6/3/15
Mel's at 22 - opened 11/17/14

498 Feet from Baseball HOF
Cooperstown Restaurant News
"The Pit" Under the Tunnicliff Inn has a new Dinner Menu and Lunch Menu. The Pepper Mill Restaurant has a new menu featuring hand-cut steaks.
Share News or a Menu - we'll post it
Be a menus star, help keep us accurate

New Cooperstown Menus
Pepper Mill Restaurant - updated 5/28/15


Steakhouse & Family Restaurant

A - F

  • Blue Mingo Grill
    6098 Rt 80, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-7496 - Seasonal

  • Bocca Osteria
    5438 Rt 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-282-4031

  • Cantina de Salsa
    149 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-4070

  • China Wok
    28 South Ave, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-5888

  • Cooperstown Back Alley Grille
    8 Hoffman Ln, Cooperstown, NY
    607-322-4048

  • Cooperstown Diner
    136 1/2 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9201

  • Cooley's Stone House Tavern
    49 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-544-1311

  • Council Rock Brewery
    4861 Rt 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-643-3016

  • Danny's Main St Market
    92 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-4053

  • DiMaggio's Cooperstown Hot Dog
    4561 RT 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-5400

  • Doubleday Cafe
    93 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-5468

  • Fly Creek Cider Mill
    288 Goose St, Fly Creek, NY
    607-547-9692

  • Foo Kin John Chinese Restaurant
    48 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-2868

  • Update a Menu
    Add/Delete a Restaurant

    G - N

  • Glimmerglass
    60 Lake St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9931

  • Hardball Cafe
    99 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-1273 - Seasonal

  • Hawkeye Grill
    60 Lake St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9931 - Otesaga Hotel

  • Jackie's Restaurant
    3688 Rt 28, Milford, NY
    607-286-7843

  • Lake Front Restaurant
    10 Fair St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9511
  • Mel's at 22
    Cuisine: Elegant Fresh American
    Good People - Good Food
    22 Chestnut St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-435-7062
    Menu | Website | Online Ordering | Facebook




  • Milford Inn & Restaurant
    104 E Main St, Milford, NY
    607-286-9525

  • Mt Fuji
    134 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-544-1088

  • New York BBQ
    4874 Rt 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-1227

  • New York Pizzeria
    75 Chestnut St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-2930

  • Nicoletta's Italian Cafe
    96 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-7499

  • Update a Menu
    Add/Delete a Restaurant

    P - R

    Pepper Mill Restaurant
    Cuisine: Steakhouse & Family Restaurant
    Hand-Cut Steaks, Burgers, Seafood, Chicken, Pasta, Kids Menu & Salad Bar. Large Parties & Team Dinners Welcome

    5418 Rt 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-8550


  • Pioneer Patio, the
    46 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-544-1076

  • Pizza Hut
    23 Commons Dr, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-1000

  • Portabello's
    6207 RT 28, Fly Creek, NY
    607-547-5145
  • Red Caboose Restaurant
    Cuisine: Rustic American w/ French Flair
    Best of central New York's farms and breweries, in the heart of historic downtown Oneonta.
    214 Main St, Oneonta, NY
    607-267-4966
    Dinner | Lunch | Dessert | Drinks | Facebook
    Redneck Bar-B-Que
    Cuisine: BBQ Steakhouse
    Where your Meat is Smoked
    And your Pork is Pulled.

    Homemade dishes, sauces and desserts.
    4874 RT 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-2678
    Website | Apps | Salads | Burgers | Sandwiches | Dinners | Facebook



  • Rose & Kettle Restaurant
    4 Lancaster St, Cherry Valley, NY, NY
    607-264-3078


  • Every Restaurant & Menu in Town
    On One Page
    - with your help

    Update a Menu
    Add/Delete a Restaurant

    S - Z

  • Sal's Pizzeria
    110 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-5721

  • Schneider's Bakery
    157 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9631

  • Slices Pizzeria
    46 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-544-1075

  • Stagecoach Coffee
    31 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-6229

  • Taylor's Village Tower
    17 Linden Ave, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9944

  • Te Pee Petes Chow Wagon
    7632 Rt 20, Cherry Valley, NY
    607-264-3987

  • "The Pit" Under The Tunnicliff Inn
    Fun, Casual, Comfortable, Family Dining
    Homemade Soups, Salads, Burgers & Sandwiches. Outstanding Steak & Seafood.
    34 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9611
    Dinner Menu | Lunch Menu

  • Toscana Italian
    64 Main St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-2100
  • Tunnicliff Inn
    17 Room Inn
    Located 498 Feet from the Baseball HOF

    34 Pioneer St, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-9611


  • Yum Yum Shack
    4918 RT 28, Cooperstown, NY
    607-547-8088 - Seasonal

  • Update a Menu
    Add/Delete a Restaurant